If there was 24 more hours I could wait and do something smart, however:
Spartan is in my group.
He has the anonymous vote ability.
I was first to post in the group (vague hints), he replied with role-claim. (Yes, I immediately kept in mind this is easy for zombies to work together with.)
He was active, then away for day and a half and was asked for his opinion on andy, so I can understand a rushed misread. Especially since he roleclaimed immediately in our group, and so would have the mindset that players would be discussing here in main thread whether we should roleclaim within our PM groups (I've made similar definition misread mistakes this game that should have been obvious to me.)
I suggested the anon vote be used on Andy sort of as a strategy to make it look "pro town" and therefore make zombies more worried about being scum-hunted. Timing issues made this attempt completely ineffective.
I don't have a read on Spartan, but since I could trust what he would do with the ability, up to this point I've been going he's not a good Day 1 lynch option.
I am posting because I'm assuming MJ has given enough reason that andy isn't the best lynch for Day 1.
So now I've made a rushed post and my group is pissed at me. Because Spartan is in my group I'm biased to considering voting Shrode. As far as I know Spartan is the other option and I'll probably get called a noob-idiot and asked to vote for Spartan. I don't know how to end this post.