Mike's Mafia Madness 2 Game Thread

[blln4lyf]

Originally Posted by mikesol

No lynch is the same as a person. If > 50% of the people vote No Lynch then it's a no lynch. It is night 1 right now.

Yeah I'm retarded, lol.

[horrordude0215]

Yeah I was just wondering why evil voted for wolf...

[Premier Stalin]

Hes probably doing it specifically to mess with you horrordude, lol.

[blln4lyf]

Originally Posted by horrordude0215

Yeah I was just wondering why evil voted for wolf...

Could be he forgot to change/saw he didn't need to change since over 50% were no no lynch..but it is a little fishy. Most likely nothing though IMO.

[Slender]

His vote for wolf and him saying to nl was almost at the same time o:

[wolf'j'max]

Yeah i'm sure he's trying to get reactions out of people for easier reads. Not sure what he would do with those N1 but whatever.

[Ribilla]

Do you guys honestly think that evil troll voting was a scumslip?

[Kennedy]

Originally Posted by Ribilla

Do you guys honestly think that evil troll voting was a scumslip?

charscharschars

[wolf'j'max]

No, not really.

[evilarsenal]

i voted for wolf, because i said i would, my vote doesnt really matter, since its majority No Lynch

i posted on the forums that yea no lynch is the logical choice, but since my vote didnt matter, i'd rather use this opportunity to mimic epic mafia and force mikesol to have an achievement award where if i vote for the mafia correctly 3 times in one game, then im like pro 1/20 or something

you guys keep talking, this is so much fun

[horrordude0215]

I don't think it's a scumslip, I just wanted to know why he did it lol. His explanation is all sorts of terribad though.

[evilarsenal]

Originally Posted by horrordude0215

I don't think it's a scumslip, I just wanted to know why he did it lol. His explanation is all sorts of terribad though.

terribad? u keep underestimating me ;_;

[horrordude0215]

It's trollish and stupid, in my honest opinion. And to say that you voted scum every day? Why are you so certain that wolf is scum in the first place?

[Ribilla]

Originally Posted by horrordude0215

It's trollish and stupid, in my honest opinion. And to say that you voted scum every day? Why are you so certain that wolf is scum in the first place?

From a game perspective Evil's actions are totally neutral and have no effect. From a scum hunting perspective he's drawing responses when there would normally be none. Last game I was talking down to evil to try and discredit his reads.

You know he's a good scum hunter, why are you trying to discredit him this game?

[blln4lyf]

Originally Posted by Ribilla

From a game perspective Evil's actions are totally neutral and have no effect. From a scum hunting perspective he's drawing responses when there would normally be none. Last game I was talking down to evil to try and discredit his reads.

You know he's a good scum hunter, why are you trying to discredit him this game?

Horror clearly just doesn't like the way Evil plays. Personanally I don't see the point in ripping him as it accomplishes nothing but I dont think it's a mafia play, I think he just REALLY dislikes evils play lol.

[horrordude0215]

Originally Posted by blln4lyf

Horror clearly just doesn't like the way Evil plays. Personanally I don't see the point in ripping him as it accomplishes nothing but I dont think it's a mafia play, I think he just REALLY dislikes evils play lol.

Pretty much this. I find it asinine and more of a distraction than anything.

[Slender]

So evil's vote doesn't matter. Let's keep talking, this is getting fun.

[evilarsenal]

Originally Posted by SlenderMan

So evil's vote doesn't matter. Let's keep talking, this is getting fun.

Such a wonderfully composed and helpful post

[Slender]

Originally Posted by evilarsenal

Such a wonderfully composed and helpful post

There's really nothing useful to add at the moment so why not write down some gibberish words into the conversation until we actually start getting useful info?

[evilarsenal]

Originally Posted by SlenderMan

There's really nothing useful to add at the moment so why not write down some gibberish words into the conversation until we actually start getting useful info?

useful info, isnt it night or something... didnt we all vote.... and day 2 voting has started and i voted for wolf... whats going on

[evilarsenal]

oh it ends today in 8 hours kk

[mikesol]

As night rolled around - EvilArsenal cautiously ventured out to try and keep an eye out for the mafia. Unfortunately, for him, the mafia recognized this. "Guiz we better kill that Evil guy. He seems pretty dangerous if left alive."

Giggling, they approached evil and brutally murdered him. Poor evil

EvilArsenal - The Watcher has been slain.

Day 2 Begins now and lasts until 9/2 at 8:00 PM. DDP may be swapping back in for Rib at some point today.

[evilarsenal]

Wolf =_________=

[Kennedy]

bomb here, ccs?

I'm surprised Mafia either didn't pick up onto my watcher breadcrumb or chose to ignore it. I'm betting I was stalked, though.

[mjolnir416]

I wouldnt be surprised if you were stalked last night, however they wouldnt be able to use that info in deciding who to kill.

[horrordude0215]

So if my math is correct we're at 3 v 6, which means we have 1 mislynch and then lylo.

Then again, it's midnight here and I'm posting in a state of virtual unconsciousness lol.

[Slender]

Originally Posted by horrordude0215

So if my math is correct we're at 3 v 6, which means we have 1 mislynch and then lylo.

Then again, it's midnight here and I'm posting in a state of virtual unconsciousness lol.

Exactly, but then again, I wouldn't know cause I'm 96.81% asleep atm

[horrordude0215]

For the record, this is why no lynching immediately isn't too good. I'll try to scour the thread for reads today, but there's a whole two pages, so yeah...

[mjolnir416]

Originally Posted by horrordude0215

For the record, this is why no lynching immediately isn't too good. I'll try to scour the thread for reads today, but there's a whole two pages, so yeah...

I don't see what you are tying to say.

[horrordude0215]

Originally Posted by mjolnir416

I don't see what you are tying to say.

We had a day one where virtually nothing happened. No chances to get reads, no chances to do anything except say "NLnowlol". Aside from a cop investigation at this point (which they should NOT out unless it's a guilty, and even then use discretion), we're back at square one.

[wolf'j'max]

Originally Posted by mjolnir416

I don't see what you are tying to say.

There's really nothing to discuss, but we need to get something out. It'd be nice to at least get something going before we have to possibly follow Kennedy for a lynch as he claimed bomb without CC's or NL again, which i don't see happening neither do i see why we should.

[mjolnir416]

Thats why I asked if we wanted to end the day early. But I would still prefer this then try and lynch someone with what we had.

[Kennedy]

We're not NLing. I kind of want to lynch Wolf since he's been pretty scummy, what do you guys think?

[Ribilla]

Posting from my.phone, so this will be short.

I don't like Kennedy's claim at all, it doesn't make any sense from a town POV, I've not seen that role before, but isn't it basically useless once the mafia know who it is? His defense is that he's been stalked anyway, but everyone knows the watcher would have been on him and mafia couldn't have known that evil was the watcher, unless he left a breadcrumb somewhere, though I can't find it. So it makes no sense for them to stalk.

No one has CC'd yet, but if they do then they are making their own role unless. (though why Kennedy would sacrifice himself to find the bomb makes no sense either - just thinking out loud here).

Thoughts?

[Kennedy]

Rib, in this situation with a dead watcher, a cop who can't claim, and a stalker, bomb should claim. Mafia would never kill me after n1 because they've stalked *someone* who they know isn't the bomb, so they always have a safe alternative to killing blindly. I would never die moving forward; I'd rather clear myself now than have to fight a CC when we don't have a mislynch.

[wolf'j'max]

Originally Posted by Kennedy

We're not NLing. I kind of want to lynch Wolf since he's been pretty scummy, what do you guys think?

I'm sorry, but how have I been scummy? Because Evil tried pressuring me early and him dying N1? I haven't really responded to Evil because I wasn't worried about it actually going through. Mafia killing evil is just a set-up to get you on my trail, if that even is what you're thinking about.

[Kennedy]

You think they'd do something that obvious? Naw, more like you killed him as a ploy to play that card; it's interesting how quickly you bring up the night kill though. Must have been on your mind.

[wolf'j'max]

Yes it has indeed been, since I haven't figured a way out how to deal with it if someone would push on me, in this case you.

To respond to Rib: I don't see why Kennedy wouldn't claim bomb right now. Without the CC's that means he's clear and we can actually get something going. If someone's actually just afk and Kennedy isn't actually the bomb we're.. well.. f'ed.

[horrordude0215]

What you guys are both engaging in is textbook WIFOM. (Wine in front of me)

For those that don't know what it is, here's how it goes:

A: Mafia killed soandso. Soandso suspected hereyago. Hereyago is therefore mafia.
B: But if the Mafia knew you'd think that, they could successfully kill soandso to throw suspicion on hereyago.
A: Yes, but we know that, so hereyago probably isn't mafia.
B: But if he is mafia, he knew we could figure that out for ourselves, so he could do it without getting suspicion thrown on him.

And so on, and so forth. It's horribly scummy and distracting, and we shouldn't do it.

[Slender]

As far as I've read, no one has been scummy at at all. Day one was nothing but what horror said "NLlol". Absolutely nothing that we've said is actually relevant. Or at least not to the point of fosing someone already.

And if I am right, we haven't even reached D2 yet.